SmallBizGenius Analysis
Pier1, now operating primarily online, receives overwhelmingly negative customer feedback regarding order fulfillment, customer service, and return policies. Many customers report issues with undelivered orders, lack of communication, and difficulty obtaining refunds, leading to accusations of scam-like practices.
Category Breakdown
Scores based on analysis of 96 recent reviews
Shipping and Delivery Issues
1.5/10Numerous customers report significant problems with shipping and delivery, including orders never arriving, delayed shipments, and lack of updates. Many reviewers state they placed orders months ago and have yet to receive their items, despite being charged.
42 reviews mention thisCustomer Service Problems
1.0/10A significant number of reviewers express extreme dissatisfaction with Pier1's customer service, citing unresponsive emails, non-existent phone support, and automated responses that fail to address their concerns. Many customers report difficulty resolving issues related to missing orders, damaged items, and returns.
58 reviews mention thisReturns and Refunds
1.5/10Many reviewers complain about Pier1's return and refund policies, stating they were offered only store credit instead of a refund to their original payment method. Some customers also report difficulties in initiating returns or receiving return labels, even for damaged or incorrect items.
35 reviews mention thisProduct Quality
3.0/10Several reviewers express disappointment with the quality of products received, describing them as cheaply made, damaged, or not as advertised. Some customers compare the current online offerings unfavorably to the quality of products previously sold in Pier1's brick-and-mortar stores.
12 reviews mention thisWebsite and Ordering Issues
2.0/10Some customers report issues with the website, including lack of order confirmations, difficulty canceling orders, and misleading product descriptions. Several reviewers also mention being charged for items that were never shipped.
15 reviews mention thisScam Accusations
1.0/10A number of reviewers explicitly accuse Pier1 of being a scam, citing experiences where they paid for items they never received and were unable to get a refund or contact customer service. Some customers also report unauthorized charges or attempts to extract more money after a purchase.
10 reviews mention thisGift Card Issues
1.5/10A few reviewers mention issues with using or redeeming Pier 1 gift cards, particularly those issued before the company's bankruptcy. Some customers report that their gift cards were not honored or that they were unable to use them online.
4 reviews mention thisPros & Cons
Common Complaints
"The order never arrived."
"Very frustrated that Pier 1 is ignoring my emails…it has been months since I paid $279 March 4, 2023 for a product that their app shows never shipped."
"Pier 1 does NOT give refunds any longer. You get a merchandise credit. What a disappointment."
"I ordered a fall wreath from Pier 1 and when I opened the box I could believe that I was charged over $80 for the cheapest looking merchandise!!"
"Bogus order # when I try the "tracking" methods."
Common Questions About Pier1
Answers derived from customer review patterns
Is Pier1 legit and trustworthy?
Based on the analyzed reviews, there are significant concerns about the legitimacy and trustworthiness of Pier1's online operations. Many customers report issues with orders not being fulfilled, lack of communication from customer service, and difficulty obtaining refunds. Several reviewers explicitly label the website a "scam." Due to these widespread negative experiences, it is advisable to exercise extreme caution before making a purchase from Pier1.
Based on 45 reviewsDoes Pier1 have good customer service?
The overwhelming consensus from the reviews is that Pier1's customer service is severely lacking. Customers consistently report difficulty reaching customer service representatives, with many stating that phone numbers are no longer valid and emails go unanswered. When customers do receive a response, it is often an automated message that does not address their specific issue. This lack of effective customer support is a major pain point for many reviewers.
Based on 58 reviewsIs Pier1 worth it for small business?
Given the numerous complaints about order fulfillment, customer service, and return policies, Pier1 is not a reliable choice for small businesses. The risk of orders not being delivered, difficulty resolving issues, and the potential for only receiving store credit instead of a refund make it a risky proposition. Small businesses need reliable vendors, and Pier1's current online operation does not appear to meet that standard.
Based on 60 reviewsWhat is Pier1's return policy like?
Based on the reviews, Pier1's return policy is a major source of frustration for customers. Many reviewers report that they were only offered store credit for returns, even when the items were damaged or not as described. Some customers also mention difficulties in initiating returns or obtaining return labels. This restrictive return policy, combined with unresponsive customer service, makes it challenging for customers to resolve issues with their purchases.
Based on 35 reviewsWhy are customers calling Pier1 a scam?
The accusations of Pier1 being a scam stem from numerous reports of customers paying for items they never receive and then being unable to get a refund or contact customer service. Some reviewers also mention unauthorized charges or attempts to extract more money after a purchase. These experiences lead customers to believe that the company is intentionally deceiving them and not fulfilling its obligations.
Based on 10 reviewsLooking for Something Different?
Compare Pier1 against 104 similar lifestyle & perks options.
View Alternatives